Skip to main content

Edition 1, 9 Nov to 16 November

What Reddit removed this week. Know the rule before you post.

Every Monday: what AutoModerator removed in 58 rooms founders post in, counted from its own public comments, with its own words for each reason.

Rooms read58subreddits where founders find customers
Removed1069+posts and comments, a floor: the busiest rooms removed more
Top reasonNew account or low karma582 removals across every room

Why posts came down

removals
New account or low karma582
Links or promotion164
Held for review101
Wrong format or place87
AI or low-effort75
Other rules60

Room by room

25 rooms removed 5 or more
ecommerce

at least 100 removed

  • New account or low karma 96Your submission in /r/ecommerce was automatically removed as your 'comment' karma is below 20 (we do not consider your total karma; your post and comment karma are separate…
  • Other rules 4Your submission in /r/ecommerce was automatically removed as the post appears to be related to Dropshipping.
legaladvice

at least 100 removed

  • New account or low karma 100Your comment was automatically removed because your account does not have enough sitewide karma.
microsaas

at least 100 removed

  • Links or promotion 100Bare link submissions aren't allowed on r/MicroSaaS. Please write a text post that introduces the topic and includes the link as supporting context.
SaaS

at least 100 removed

  • New account or low karma 5Your post has been removed because your account is less than 7 days old. Take time to participate in the community before posting.
  • Links or promotion 19Your comment was removed. Links in comments require to gain karma first in r/SaaS. Earn sub karma by commenting helpfully first.
  • AI or low-effort 75Low-Effort/AI content is auto-removed.
  • Other rules 1Your post has been removed because your Reddit email is not verified.
shopify

at least 100 removed

  • New account or low karma 100Your submission in /r/shopify was automatically removed as your 'post' karma is below 10 (we do not consider your total karma; your post and comment karma are separate numbers and…
cscareerquestions

at least 98 removed

  • New account or low karma 95Sorry, you do not meet the minimum sitewide comment karma requirement of 10 to post a comment.
  • Other rules 3Sorry, your submission to /r/CSCareerQuestions has been automatically removed. Please save interview discussion, advice, and critique requests for the weekly stickied thread.
NewTubers

at least 80 removed

  • Links or promotion 15AltruisticHighway316, your submission was removed automatically: - Reason: Link in title (video plugs not allowed) - For details: Read our rules Need feedback? Join our Discord…
  • Held for review 64This post has been filtered for manual review, which may take 72 hours.
  • Other rules 1SubToAstor, your submission was removed. /r/NewTubers does not allow video plugs.
marketing

at least 76 removed

  • New account or low karma 76Your account must be 30+ days old and it must have 300+ karma to post in r/Marketing
growmybusiness

53 removed

  • Wrong format or place 53Hi there! I regret to tell you that your post has been removed because you didn't include one of the required title tags.
Wordpress

52 removed

  • New account or low karma 1Your submission has been automatically removed because you have less than 1 karma.
  • Links or promotion 13Your link post submission has been automatically removed because your reddit account is less than a month old. Your reddit account must be older than 30 days to post links.
  • Wrong format or place 6Your submission has been automatically removed because the title contains words that suggest the post is against the /r/WordPress posting rules (no hosting-related questions).
  • Held for review 21Your submission has been filtered for moderator review because your post topic is frequently associated with advertising.
  • Other rules 11Your submission has been automatically removed because it may be about WordPress.com.
Entrepreneur

24 removed

  • New account or low karma 24READ THIS WHOLE MESSAGE Your post has been removed as you have not earned enough subreddit karma to contribute here as a poster.
kickstarter

24 removed

  • Wrong format or place 16The submission has been automatically removed. Please delete and repost it with a more descriptive title.
  • Other rules 8"Hi, Your recent post (this one: has been automatically removed because your account is not one month old.
podcasting

19 removed

  • New account or low karma 19This post was removed because the poster's account's karma is less than 5. This is a measure to reduce spam.
DigitalMarketing

at least 18 removed

  • New account or low karma 18Your submission has been automatically removed because you are new to our community. If you are new to marketing or just new here, post your question to /r/AskMarketing instead.
content_marketing

15 removed

  • New account or low karma 15Your submission has been automatically removed because you are new to our community, spend more time contributing with your comments before posting.
learnprogramming

14 removed

  • Links or promotion 1Your post was automatically removed because it appears to contain only a link. Link-only posts are not allowed in this subreddit. If you are trying to: 1.
  • Other rules 13Your post/comment was removed since we do not approve of going private. There is zero benefit in going private as you lose the opportunity for getting peer reviews.
photography

13 removed

  • Held for review 13Your post has been filtered for manual review. This is an automatic spam-prevention measure. Filtered posts are checking in the order in which they are received.
advertising

at least 12 removed

  • New account or low karma 12Your submission has been automatically removed because you are new to our community. If you are new to marketing or just new here, post your question to /r/AskMarketing instead.
sweatystartup

11 removed

  • New account or low karma 11In an effort to fight spam and low effort posts, your post/comment has been removed due to account age or karma.
web_design

11 removed

  • Other rules 11Your post has been automatically removed. Please participate around reddit by commenting on other posts before you jump straight to submitting.
EtsySellers

10 removed

  • Wrong format or place 9It looks like your post may be about a drop in sales or views. Please be advised that we don't allow posts about this topic outside of our monthly stickied post.
  • Other rules 1Mod Note: If you are posting about a listing deactivation, you must provide specific details.
blogging

8 removed

  • Links or promotion 8Link posts are not allowed on this subreddit. Please read the rules of /r/Blogging. If you are still left with doubts, contact the mods.
startups

8 removed

  • New account or low karma 5Your submission was removed because your account link + comment karma might mean spam. You can check your account karma at .
  • Wrong format or place 3Your submission was removed, all feedback requests belong in the weekly feedback thread. If you believe this was a mistake please contact us via ModMail
Upwork

7 removed

  • Links or promotion 7Hiring and looking for work posts are not allowed in this subreddit. Look into r/forhire and affiliated subreddits. If this is a mistake just remove -hiring- from your title
digital_marketing

5 removed

  • New account or low karma 5Your submission has been automatically removed because you are new to our community. If you are new to marketing or just new here, post your question to /r/AskMarketing instead.

Fewer than 5 this week

33 rooms

r/AmazonSeller, r/graphic_design, r/programming, r/devops, r/FulfillmentByAmazon, r/reactjs, r/Accounting, r/advancedentrepreneur, r/AlphaAndBetaUsers, r/AppIdeas, r/AskMarketing, r/bigseo, r/buildinpublic, r/Construction, r/copywriting, r/Emailmarketing, r/Etsy, r/GrowthHacking, r/hvacadvice, r/IMadeThis, r/newsletters, r/personaltraining, r/PPC, r/ProductHunters, r/realtors, r/restaurateur, r/roastmystartup, r/SideProject, r/smallbusiness, r/socialmedia, r/Substack, r/woocommerce, r/ycombinator.

A quiet room is not a safe room. Bans, shadow removals and human moderators leave no comment to count.

Get the Removal Index every Monday

One email a week: what each room removed, in AutoModerator's own words. Free.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Read on 16 November from the public Arctic Shift mirror of Reddit: every comment AutoModerator left in each room over the last 7 days, up to 100 a room. A comment counts only when its own words say a post or comment was removed, filtered, held for review or turned away; pinned reminders and welcome notes do not count. The mirror returns 100 comments at most, so a room at 100 removed more. Check a room's promotion rule before you post: subreddit self-promotion rules. Built by Kasspian, which finds people asking for what you sell and checks your reply is still up.